MIG vs TIG vs Stick- Which Is the Best Option

October 25, 2021

Emmanuel

I am a professional welder with over 10 years of experience. Welding is my first love and writing is my second. I enjoy writing on welding topics.

Which is better between MIG, TIG, and stick welding? The answer is that there is no “best option.” The differences between TIG, MIG, and stick welding mean that they all have their purposes and places.

  • Each process has its advantages and limitations. You have to find the welding process best suited for your application. TIG is preferred for intricate welds where quality and appearance matter more than efficiency. Stick welding is the easiest process making it suitable for large industrial applications. MIG is known for speed and efficiency making it the ideal choice for applications where a high production rate is desired.

TIG

How Does TIG Compare to MIG and Stick Welding

TIG is slower than MIG. However, it is more precise than MIG. Compared to the other processes, it can work at much lower amperages making it useful for thinner metals and exotic welds. The number one choice for high-quality welding is TIG. When quality and precision are the most desired aspects in a weld, TIG welding will be chosen.

Why Should You Choose TIG Over MIG and Stick?

  • It welds more alloys and metals than MIG and Stick

TIG can be used to weld a wide range of metals including nickel, magnesium, aluminum, steel, gold, and bronze among others

  • Welds in all positions

With TIG, you can weld in all positions such as vertical, horizontal, flat, and overhead. Thus, it is perfect for inside confined spaces and even roll cages.

  • Creates clean and high-quality welds

With weld puddle control and a superior arc, TIG makes it possible to create clean and neat welds if appearance is an important aspect. TIG allows you to control the heat input with a foot pedal, thus you can easily cool down or heat the weld allowing for a high level of precision. That makes TIG the perfect choice for cosmetic welds such as automotive welds and sculptures.

The TIG process is free of sparks, spatter, slag, flux, fumes, and smoke. TIG will only create smoke if the base metal has contaminants or elements such as paint, grease, or oil. To avoid smoke, the base metal needs to be cleaned before you start welding. Spatter and sparks are not produced because only the right level of filler metal is used.

What Are The Limitations of TIG?

TIG is a popular welding process. However, it has several limitations including:

  • It needs more welder skills compared to stick welding or MIG. TIG is comparatively more difficult to master.
  • It is significantly slower than MIG, stick welding, and other welding techniques.
  • TIG costs more when welding thick metal sections.
  • It has a lower disposition rate.

MIG

How Does MIG Welding Compare To TIG?

Several factors make MIG welding better than TIG. While TIG can be used on a wide variety of metals, it is not effective for thicker jobs.

  • The main difference between MIG and TIG is that TIG is ideal for thin materials while MIG is perfect for thick materials.

How Does MIG Welding Compare To Stick Welding?

  • Skill level

Stick welding is easy to learn; therefore, it is great for beginners. It is also affordable. It is complicated to set up MIG machines, learning the MIG process is also complex and expensive. If you are a beginner or you are not seriously into welding, stick welding will be your best choice. If you are a professional welder or an advanced hobbyist, you can take the time to learn MIG.

  • Cleanliness

The results of stick welding are not clean but they are strong. If you don’t care about appearance but you desire strength, you can opt for Stick as long as you are willing to dedicate some time to sand and clean your weld. In contrast, MIG is cleaner compared to stick welding. It is also more efficient and faster.

Advantages: Why is MIG Welding Better than TIG and Stick?

  • Speed

Compared to TIG and Stick, MIG is the winner when it comes to speed. A MIG gun will run continuously for a long time. It is more productive and efficient than the other two processes. For an industrial application where speed is of the essence and a high production rate is desired, MIG should be the ultimate choice.

  • Cost

Speed translates to efficiency which makes MIG cost-effective. The parts of a MIG machine are readily available and they cost less than that of a TIG machine.

  • Ease

With MIG, you just pull a trigger to start or stop the welding process. The MIG gun can be operated with one hand. However, TIG welding is a specialized technique that has to be carried out with both your hands and one foot.

Limitations of MIG Welding

  • The initial setup cost is higher.
  • Higher maintenance costs.
  • Can easily be affected with radiation compared to other welding processes.
  • Setting a MIG plant requires a high skill level.
  • The environment surrounding the MIG process must be stable.

STICK WELDING

What Distinguishes Stick Welding from MIG and TIG?

Stick welding can be carried out outdoors because wind cannot affect it, unlike TIG and MIG which can only happen indoors. MIG and TIG use gas cylinders but that is not the case with Stick.

Advantages: Why Is Stick Welding Better Than TIG and MIG?

  • Simplicity

Stick welding compared to TIG and MIG, is the easiest welding process to learn. The simplicity of stick welding makes it popular; it makes use of simple equipment. The entire Stick setup simply involves an electrode, welding machine, and power source.

Due to its simplicity, stick welding is widely used for industrial applications compared to TIG and MIG. It is the most dominant welding process when it comes to the fabrication of heavy steel structures.

  • Portability

Because no wire feeder or shielding gas is needed, stick welding is very portable.

  • Versatility

It can be used indoors and outdoors even in windy conditions.

Limitations of Stick Welding

  • Inefficient because changing electrodes and increased cleanup time will reduce productivity.
  • It produces lower quality weld compared to TIG and MIG.
  • Produces spatter and slag.

The Bottom-Line

In welding, there is no “best process.” You need to choose what is right for you. Factors to consider include metal type, nature of your application, quality desired, and your budget.

You May Also Like…

All you need to know about the hardships of welding jobs

All you need to know about the hardships of welding jobs

Among all the jobs in the welding industry, welders are the most paid ones. Welders have a great demand in the current market. Almost every industry requires the use of welders for the construction of their machines. Due to this ongoing requirement of welders, they...

Acetylene or Propane? Which one’s better?

Acetylene or Propane? Which one’s better?

Several industries apply welding techniques for the construction of machines and other structures. This increase in demand for the welding process leads to further advancements in the process. Earlier, there were only a few techniques of welding. Whereas now, there...